SOC 2 with AI

Run a SOC 2 Gap Assessment with AI

The short answer

A SOC 2 self assessment compares what your company does today with the common criteria, CC1 to CC9, before an auditor does. An AI assistant can run the interview: it asks, you answer, score each criterion from 0 to 3 on the scoring sheet and turn every low score into a task. A self-assessment gives no auditor’s opinion. It tells you what to fix before the examination.

Key takeaways

  • The assistant asks; you answer and score. It cannot see your systems, so every answer needs a record you can name.
  • The scoring sheet is a CSV. It works as a spreadsheet with no AI at all.
  • The result is a worklist, not a report. Only a licensed CPA firm issues a SOC 2 report with an opinion.

How do I run a SOC 2 gap assessment myself?

  1. Set the scope: the product, its systems and the Trust Services Categories. See how to scope systems for SOC 2.
  2. Open the criteria. Download the AICPA Trust Services Criteria: nine series of common criteria, CC1 to CC9, 33 criteria in all.
  3. Interview, series by series. Answer from what happens today, not from what a policy says.
  4. Fill in the sheet. One row per criterion: what you do, the evidence that exists, a score.
  5. Turn gaps into tasks, each with an owner and a date.

Have the person who does the work answer, not the person who wrote the policy. The SOC 2 readiness checklist covers the wider readiness work; SOC 2 with AI shows the whole workflow.

What is in the SOC 2 gap assessment scoring sheet?

Download the gap assessment scoring sheet (CSV). It works as a spreadsheet with no AI at all. It has one row for each of the 33 common criteria, with Series, Series name and Criterion filled in. You complete the rest:

  • What the criterion asks (in your words). Restate it; the sheet does not reproduce the AICPA’s text.
  • What we do today. The practice as it is.
  • Evidence that exists (system, export, ticket, record). Where someone else could see it.
  • Score (0-3). From the scale below.
  • Gap to close, Owner, Target date, Notes. The task that follows.
The 0 to 3 scale of the gap assessment scoring sheet.
ScoreMeaning
0Not in place
1Done informally, nothing written
2In place and written, no evidence kept
3In place, written, and evidence exists for the whole period

Give a 3 only when you can name the record. For a Type II report, “the whole period” is the period the report covers; see SOC 2 Type I vs Type II.

What should I ask an AI assistant for each series, CC1 to CC9?

Describe your product, systems and team first, then run one prompt per series. The topics are a plain-language summary of each series, not the text of the criteria: read the criteria before you score.

CC1: Control Environment

SOC 2 gap assessment, CC1 Control Environment. Ask me, question by question, what we do today about conduct rules, management oversight, reporting lines, hiring checks, training and accountability, and what record shows each. Do not score. Flag every assumption.
List anything you assumed that I need to verify.

CC2: Communication and Information

SOC 2 gap assessment, CC2 Communication and Information. Ask me, question by question, how security duties reach employees today, how people report concerns, what we tell customers about commitments, changes and incidents, and what record shows each. Do not score. Flag every assumption.
List anything you assumed that I need to verify.

CC3: Risk Assessment

SOC 2 gap assessment, CC3 Risk Assessment. Ask me, question by question, how we identify and rate risks today, whether fraud and major changes are considered, who approved the last assessment, and what record shows each. Do not score. Flag every assumption.
List anything you assumed that I need to verify.

CC4: Monitoring Activities

SOC 2 gap assessment, CC4 Monitoring Activities. Ask me, question by question, how we check today that controls still work, who checks, how shortcomings are tracked until fixed, and what record shows each. Do not score. Flag every assumption.
List anything you assumed that I need to verify.

CC5: Control Activities

SOC 2 gap assessment, CC5 Control Activities. Ask me, question by question, how we choose controls for our risks today, which ones technology enforces, how policies become procedures people follow, and what record shows each. Do not score. Flag every assumption.
List anything you assumed that I need to verify.

CC6: Logical and Physical Access Controls

SOC 2 gap assessment, CC6 Logical and Physical Access Controls. Ask me, question by question, how access is granted, authenticated, reviewed and removed today, how data and devices are protected, who can enter rooms that hold systems, and what record shows each. Do not score. Flag every assumption.
List anything you assumed that I need to verify.

CC7: System Operations

SOC 2 gap assessment, CC7 System Operations. Ask me, question by question, how we find vulnerabilities today, what we monitor, who gets alerts, how an incident runs from detection to recovery, and what record shows each. Do not score. Flag every assumption.
List anything you assumed that I need to verify.

CC8: Change Management

SOC 2 gap assessment, CC8 Change Management. Ask me, question by question, how a change to code or infrastructure is reviewed, tested, approved and deployed today, who can skip a step, and what record shows each. Do not score. Flag every assumption.
List anything you assumed that I need to verify.

CC9: Risk Mitigation

SOC 2 gap assessment, CC9 Risk Mitigation. Ask me, question by question, how we prepare for business disruption today, how we choose and review vendors and business partners, and what record shows each. Do not score. Flag every assumption.
List anything you assumed that I need to verify.

Check the assistant’s summary, then copy it into the sheet. The SOC 2 controls list gives example controls for each series.

How do I turn SOC 2 gaps into a task list?

  1. Filter the sheet to scores below 3.
  2. Write each “Gap to close” as an action that ends in a record: “Review production access each quarter and save the signed review”.
  3. Give each task one owner and a target date.
  4. Do the 0s and 1s first: a control or a written rule is missing. A 2 only lacks a record.
  5. Score the row again when the task is done.

A score of 1 often calls for a written rule: see SOC 2 policies with AI. A score of 2 is an evidence problem: see collecting SOC 2 evidence with an AI agent. AI-written policies and descriptions are acceptable only if they describe what your company actually does. The audit tests how controls operate, not how documents read.

For a Type II report, close the gaps before the period starts: a control that starts late cannot be shown to have operated for the whole period. See the SOC 2 audit timeline and the most common SOC 2 findings.

Who does what

A self-assessment is management’s own work and gives no auditor’s opinion. In the Zero-Platform SOC 2 Audit, Auditsuisse explains the criteria, requests evidence and tests the controls. It does not choose your controls or close your gaps: AI-guided preparation, CPA-performed audit.

Who does what when you run a SOC 2 gap assessment with AI.
TaskYour team (with or without AI)Your AI assistantThe auditor
Set the scopeDecides the product, systems and categoriesExplains terms and suggests questionsConfirms the scope in the engagement letter
Describe and score current practiceAnswers for each criterion, names the evidence and gives the scoreAsks the questions; points out answers with no recordNo role. A self-assessment carries no opinion
Close the gapsAssigns owners and dates, puts controls in placeDrafts task wording from your decisionsNo role
ExaminationProvides evidence and management’s assertionNo roleRequests evidence, tests the controls and issues the report with the opinion

Frequently asked questions

Is a SOC 2 self-assessment the same as a readiness assessment?

The terms overlap. A gap assessment, or gap analysis, compares your current controls with the criteria. A readiness assessment usually also covers scope, the system description and evidence preparation. Neither produces an opinion.

Can an AI assistant score our controls?

No. It can ask the questions and point out an answer with no record behind it. It cannot see your systems unless you give it access. The score is yours.

Does a self-assessment with all 3s mean a clean report?

No. A self-assessment gives no auditor’s opinion and predicts none. The auditor requests evidence, tests the controls and forms the opinion from those tests.

Sources & further reading

AICPA, 2017 Trust Services Criteria (with revised points of focus, 2022); SSAE No. 18, AT-C sections 105 and 205.

Related: SOC 2 risk assessment with AI, SOC 2 Trust Services Criteria.

Product names are trademarks of their owners. Auditsuisse is not affiliated with these vendors.

Sébastien Ruosch

Work with a licensed CPA firm

Auditsuisse Assurance NA PC is a licensed US CPA firm, enrolled in the AICPA Peer Review Program and authorized to perform SOC 2 examinations and issue SOC 2 reports. You prepare; we examine your evidence. See the Zero-Platform SOC 2 audit or book a scoping call.

Back to top ↑