SOC 2

Qualified vs Unqualified SOC 2 Opinion: Can You Fail a SOC 2 Audit?

The short answer

You cannot pass or fail a SOC 2 examination. The auditor issues one of four opinions. An unmodified opinion, often called unqualified or clean, means the description is fairly presented and controls were suitably designed and, for Type 2, operated effectively. A qualified opinion means that is true except for a specified matter.

Key takeaways

  • Exceptions and qualifications are different things. Many reports with exceptions still carry an unmodified opinion.
  • A qualification applies to specific criteria and is explained in the report.
  • Adverse opinions and disclaimers are rare, because problems that severe usually surface before the report is issued.
  • Readers care about what went wrong and what was done about it, more than the label.

The four opinions

OpinionMeaning
Unmodified (unqualified)Fairly presented, suitably designed and operating effectively, in all material respects
QualifiedAs above, except for the matter described
AdverseThe description is misstated or controls were not suitably designed or effective, pervasively
DisclaimerThe auditor could not obtain enough evidence to form an opinion

How an exception becomes a qualification

An exception is a single deviation found in testing. The auditor then asks: how many deviations, in how large a sample? Was there a compensating control? Did the criterion as a whole still get met? If the answer to the last question is no, the opinion is qualified for that criterion.

Example: one of forty sampled changes lacked documented approval, and code review still occurred. This is likely reported as an exception with an unmodified opinion. If approvals were missing for a large share of changes across the period, the change management criterion may not be met.

What to do with exceptions

Management can include a response in the report: the cause, what was fixed and when. A clear response reassures readers. Then fix the root cause before the next period. See most common SOC 2 findings.

How to lower the risk

Run a readiness assessment before the period starts, choose a first period you can sustain, and monitor recurring controls monthly so a missed task is caught early. See the SOC 2 readiness checklist.

Frequently asked questions

Will customers reject a qualified report?

Some will ask questions; few reject outright if the matter is narrow and remediated.

Can the auditor remove an exception if I fix it?

No. The report reflects what happened in the period.

Does a Type 1 report have exceptions?

A Type 1 report addresses design at a date, so it has no operating-effectiveness test results.

Sources & further reading

AICPA AT-C section 205; AICPA SOC 2 Guide.

Related: What is SOC 2 Type 2, How to read a SOC 2 report.

Sébastien Ruosch

Work with a licensed CPA firm

Auditsuisse Assurance NA PC is a licensed US CPA firm enrolled in the AICPA Peer Review Program. See our published SOC 2 fees or book a scoping call.

Back to top ↑